Dress codes, decoded

    Formal, smart casual, the Morning Room exception and the matter of the sunglasses. What the rules actually say, room by room.

    By
    The Index
    Published
    Length
    4 minute read
    Annabel's, Berkeley Square

    Club dress codes are written in a language that sounds precise and is not. "Smart casual" means something different on Pall Mall, in Edinburgh and in Soho. "Formal" rarely means black tie. And the rule that matters most is often the one about a single room at a particular hour.

    The good news is that the clubs that care most about dress also tend to write it down. Here is what a few of them actually say.

    Formal, as the clubs mean it

    At the Carlton Club, register No. 040 in St James's, formal dress in the public rooms means, for men, "tailored jacket and formal trousers or suit, together with a collared shirt and tie". For women it means a trouser suit, skirt or dress. Official national dress and service uniform are welcome. That is the house standard, and it is a useful definition to carry elsewhere: where a club spells it out, formal means a jacket and tie, not a dinner jacket.

    At The New Club in Edinburgh the weekday rule is the same in spirit. Gentlemen are expected to wear a jacket and tie; ladies "should dress in business attire, elegant dress, separates or smart trousers". Jeans should not be worn.

    The Travellers Club, register No. 027 on Pall Mall is formal at all times, which at least saves anyone the trouble of reading a timetable.

    Smart casual, defined at last

    The phrase is everywhere and is almost never explained. The New Club does explain it: smart casual means "no jacket or tie, not jeans". At the Carlton it means, for men, "tailored trousers and a smart collared shirt", and for women tailored trousers, skirt or dress.

    Both clubs agree on the list of things that are never acceptable, and it is worth memorising, because it is close to universal. The Carlton bans "denim clothing, jeans, shorts, leggings, t-shirts, trainers, sports clothing". The New Club's list adds tracksuits. Neither will make an exception because the jeans were expensive.

    Where a club spells it out, formal means a jacket and tie, not a dinner jacket.

    The clock and the room

    The real skill is reading the exceptions, which are about time and place.

    • By the hour. At the Carlton, smart casual is allowed throughout the clubhouse at weekends and on weekdays before 11 in the morning. In its Morning Room between 9am and 5.30pm the code relaxes further and men may take off their jackets and ties.
    • By the day. At The New Club, smart casual is allowed throughout the club on Saturdays and Sundays, with one firm exception: apart from breakfast, a jacket and tie for gentlemen, and equivalent formality for ladies, is always required in the Main Dining Room.
    • By the room. The New Club's Bayle's Bar and Billiard Room take smart casual every day. In the Long Room and on the balcony at lunch, no tie is required.
    • In transit. Members going to or from their bedroom or the gym without passing through the public rooms are excused. Nobody is expected to wear a tie to the treadmill.

    The lesson, if you are a guest, is to dress for the strictest room you might be shown into, not the one you expect to sit in. The Carlton is clear that inappropriately dressed members or guests will be asked to leave, and that a member should make sure guests know the rules before they arrive.

    Annabel's, and the art of the joke

    Night clubs write their dress codes in a different key. Under its founder Mark Birley, Annabel's in Berkeley Square required a dark suit and tie. In 2017 the club asked Derek Blasberg to write a new code, and he produced one that is widely read as tongue in cheek. Among its exclusions: "cheap, ill-fitting suits", "visible nipples", "sunglasses at night" and "couples dressing the same". Smart trainers, once unthinkable, were allowed.

    It is a joke, and it is also a perfectly serious rule, which is the point. The old code said: dress like everyone else here. The new one says: dress like you meant to.

    The houses that say less

    Soho House is famously relaxed, and its house rules ask only that members and guests "should be mindful of the events they host and how they dress", to keep the houses casual and relaxed. The rules say more about cameras, which are not allowed, than about collars. That, too, is a dress code of sorts: the uniform is not a tie, it is discretion.

    A short glossary

    • Formal. In the clubs quoted here: jacket and tie for men, the equivalent for women. Not black tie unless the invitation says so.
    • Smart casual. No tie, probably no jacket, never jeans. Ask which; the answer differs by house.
    • Jacket required. Jacket on in the public rooms, tie optional. Find out which rooms are public.
    • National dress and uniform. Generally welcome, and explicitly so at both the Carlton and The New Club.
    • Trainers. No, unless the club has said yes in writing. Annabel's has.

    Every club page in our register records the dress code where the club has published one. When in doubt, wear the tie. It is easier to take off than to find.

    Sources

    1. Dress code, Carlton Club
    2. Dress code, The New Club, Edinburgh
    3. Travellers Club, Wikipedia
    4. Annabel's, Wikipedia
    5. Annabel's London club, Country & Town House
    6. House Rules, Soho House

    Spotted an error? Tell the register. We correct the record.

    Clubs in this piece

    2 entries in the register

    • Carlton Club, London
      No. 040St James's

      Carlton Club

      London · Est. 1832 · By nomination